Skip to main content

Choosing the right reward setup for your loyalty program

A practical guide to choosing between free product rewards, discount code rewards, minimum-order unlocks, and fixed coupon ladders.

Written by Stuart Chaney
Updated this week

Introduction

If you are deciding how customers should redeem rewards, start by matching the reward type to your product mix, average order value, and how often customers buy from you.

This guide covers four common reward setups and when each one works best:

  • Free product redemption

  • Basic checkout discount code rewards

  • Minimum-order reward unlocks

  • Fixed coupon ladders (like $5, $10, $20, $50)




Your reward options in Rivo

From Programs > Points under Redeeming Points, click Add Another Reward to add reward types for your online store.

You can create:

  • Amount Discount

  • Percentage Off

  • Free Shipping

  • Free Product

✨ Free Shipping and Free Product rewards require access to Advanced Rewards.




1) Free product redemption

Free product rewards are best when the product itself is a strong incentive.

Best fit

  • Product-led brands that want customers to discover specific items

  • Brands with strong repeat purchase behavior

  • Stores where a free item has clear perceived value


Why teams choose it

  • Drives attention to a specific product

  • Feels more tangible than a generic discount

  • Works well for sampling and product discovery


Important setup notes

  • Select the exact product when configuring the reward

  • You can set a Minimum Cart Requirement for free product rewards

  • For free product rewards, you can choose either:

  • Minimum cart value

  • Minimum order quantity

  • You can only use one minimum requirement type at a time

Important: Customers need the selected product in cart for the reward to apply.




2) Basic checkout discount code rewards

This is the simplest and most broadly effective setup: customers redeem points for a straightforward discount code.

Best fit

  • Stores that want the lowest-friction redemption flow

  • Brands with broad catalogs

  • Teams optimizing for easy customer understanding


Why teams choose it

  • Easy to explain in marketing and onsite messaging

  • Works across many product types

  • Fast for customers to understand and use


Common starting point

A typical structure is a simple amount-off reward, then expanding based on performance.

For step-by-step setup, see Fixed Amount Discount Reward.




3) Minimum-order reward unlocks

Minimum-order unlocks let you require a cart threshold before a reward can be applied.

Best fit

  • Brands trying to lift average order value

  • Teams that want rewards to drive larger baskets

  • Stores balancing reward generosity with margin protection


Why teams choose it

  • Encourages larger carts

  • Gives you more control over when rewards are used

  • Can protect margins compared to unrestricted discounts


How it works in setup

In each reward, use Minimum Cart Requirement and choose:

  • None

  • Minimum cart value

  • Minimum order quantity (available for free product rewards)




4) Fixed coupon ladders ($5 / $10 / $20 / $50)

A fixed coupon ladder offers multiple amount-off options at increasing point costs.

Best fit

  • Teams that want customers to choose between quick wins and bigger goals

  • Stores with mixed AOV where one discount level is not enough

  • Programs focused on progression and ongoing engagement


Why teams choose it

  • Creates visible progression

  • Supports different customer budgets and basket sizes

  • Easy to tune by adding or adjusting reward tiers


Default ladder behavior

New loyalty setups include amount-off rewards at:

  • $5 off for 100 points

  • $10 off for 200 points

  • $20 off for 400 points

You can add more tiers (for example, $50 off) by creating additional Amount Discount rewards.




Use reward value rate to sanity-check your setup

In Programs > Points, the Setup Overview card shows your Reward value rate.

A common example:

  • Customers earn 1 point for every $1 spent

  • A reward costs 100 points and gives $5 off

  • Effective reward value rate = 5%

Use this to keep your program attractive to customers while staying aligned with your margins.




Quick decision guide

If you want a fast decision:

  • Choose Free Product when product experience is your strongest loyalty lever

  • Choose Basic checkout discount codes when you want simple, broad adoption

  • Choose Minimum-order unlocks when your main goal is higher average order value

  • Choose a Fixed coupon ladder when you want clear progression across customer segments

When unsure, start with basic discount codes, measure redemption behavior, then add minimum requirements or a ladder as your program matures.




Related articles

Did this answer your question?